Faire, which runs a wholesale marketplace for independent shops, suggests reaching the owner or buyer directly, in person or by email. It also says those owners are inundated with generic, one-size-fits-all emails from brands. Your email has to look like it was written for their shop, and it has to carry the numbers a buyer needs to say yes.
This guide covers what to prepare, when to pitch, three email templates and how to send the follow-ups. Facts come from Faire and Shopify guides checked on 2026-10-31.
Before you email: get your numbers ready
Wholesale price
Shops price on keystone. Faire describes it as a wholesale price roughly 50% of the retail price, and the shop then doubles the wholesale cost to arrive at the retail price.
So a candle you sell for $32 on your own site goes to a shop for about $16. Check that $16 still covers your product cost, packaging and shipping to the shop. Our product pricing guide walks through the cost side.
Minimums and case sizes
A case size is the fewest units of one product you sell, and an order minimum is the smallest total a shop must spend. Faire recommends keeping case sizes fewer than 10 and keeping first-order minimums on the lower end, so a shop can try your line without much risk.
The line sheet
A line sheet is one or two pages a buyer can order from. Faire lists what it should hold:
- a photo of each product
- SKUs or item numbers
- wholesale and suggested retail prices
- minimums and case sizes
- ordering information and terms (payment, lead time, shipping)
Save it as a PDF or a shareable link. Put your store URL on it so the buyer can see the products in context. For a full example with terms, a product table and an order form, see how to make a line sheet boutiques can order from.
Pick the right shops
Faire suggests visiting the store as a customer first, to see what it carries and who shops there. Online, that means their website and Instagram. You are looking for:
- products near your price point
- a style your product fits next to
- no direct copy of what you make already on their shelves
Write one line per shop about why you fit. That line is what separates your email from the generic ones. Start with 20 shops you studied, and add more once the pitch gets replies.
When to pitch
Faire says retailers stock up for the holidays from about May to October, and that searches for seasonal moments take off two to four months ahead. If you want to be on shelves in December, July is not early.
Template 1: the first email
Keep it short. Faire says independent shop owners prefer a personal approach over a formal pitch deck.
Subject: [Product type] for [Shop name]’s [section, e.g. “home corner”]
Hi [First name],
I’ve been following [Shop name] for a while. [Your one personal line, e.g. “Your autumn window with the dried flower bundles is why I’m writing.”]
I make [product] in [city/state]. [One line on what makes it different, e.g. “Soy candles in reusable stoneware, scents built around local trees.”] They retail at $[price] and wholesale at $[price], with a first order of [minimum].
Line sheet: [link]
If it looks like a fit, I’m happy to send a sample.
[Your name], [Store name] · [store URL]
This is a wholesale offer from [Business name], [postal address]. Reply “no thanks” and I won’t email again.
The last line covers what US law asks of a commercial email: who you are, your postal address and a way to opt out. Our cold email tools comparison has the full CAN-SPAM checklist.
Template 2: the first follow-up (about a week later)
Faire calls follow-ups expected, not pushy and suggests two or three, spaced about a week apart.
Subject: Re: [original subject]
Hi [First name],
Following up in case this got buried. [One new detail: a best seller, a new scent, a shop that already stocks you, or a photo of the product on a shelf.]
Line sheet again: [link]
[Your name]
Template 3: the last follow-up (a week after that)
Subject: Re: [original subject]
Hi [First name],
Last note from me. If the timing is wrong, I’d love to know when you plan [season] buying so I can check back then.
Happy to send a sample either way.
[Your name]
Shopify’s guide to getting stocked in stores suggests the same pattern in person: leave samples and information, then follow up.
How to send it
For your first 20 to 50 shops, sending from your normal inbox and following up by hand is fine. Keep a sheet with the date of each email and whether the shop replied.
Past that, follow-ups become most of the work. With 200 shops and three emails each, you are filtering a spreadsheet and sending a few hundred follow-ups by hand, on the right day, without emailing anyone who already answered. This is the job a sequence tool does:
- Instantly sends each step on schedule, stops when a buyer replies, and lets you send from several warmed-up inboxes on a second domain, so outreach stays away from your order emails. Growth is $47 a month for 5,000 emails.
- Gmail mail merge handles the first send for up to 1,500 recipients a day, but the follow-ups stay manual.
- lemlist works like Instantly and is priced per user, which suits a team.
Our Gmail vs Instantly vs lemlist comparison has the limits, prices and a worked example for 200 boutiques.
Whichever you use, set up SPF and DKIM on your domain first (domain and email setup guide), and warm up any new inbox for about two weeks before you start.
Common mistakes
- No prices in the email. Put both prices and your minimum in the email so the buyer does not have to ask.
- Attaching a large deck. A link to a one-page line sheet is easier to open on a phone.
- The same email to every shop. Faire’s point about generic emails is the reason for the personal line.
- One email and done. Plan two or three follow-ups before you send the first.
- Pitching for the holidays in November. Shops do that buying months earlier.
Sources (checked 2026-10-31)
- Faire: From D2C to wholesale: wholesale price roughly 50% of retail.
- Faire: Ecommerce pricing: retailers double the wholesale cost.
- Faire: Wholesale basics: case sizes under 10, first-order minimums on the lower end, definitions.
- Faire: How to get your product in stores: line sheet contents, visit the store first, personal approach over a pitch deck, two or three follow-ups about a week apart.
- Faire: How to send effective emails: retailers receive many generic brand emails.
- Faire: When to pitch retailers: holiday stocking May to October, searches two to four months ahead.
- Shopify: Get products stocked in retail stores: samples and follow-up.
- Instantly: Pricing and Google: Mail merge in Gmail: plan limits quoted above.

