Skip to content

Pitching Stockists and Creators by Email: Gmail Mail Merge vs Instantly vs lemlist

Emailing boutiques, gift buyers or creators and hearing nothing back? Gmail mail merge, Instantly and lemlist compared on follow-ups, spam risk and price.

8 min read
Megaphone, camera, and magnifier around a smartphone screen

Quick answer

If you pitch stockists or creators more than once, Instantly Growth ($47/month, or $37.60 billed yearly) is the pick: it sends your follow-ups on a schedule, stops when someone replies, and spreads sending over as many warmed-up inboxes as you like, for 5,000 emails a month. Gmail mail merge (Google Workspace Business Standard, $14/user/month on an annual plan) works for testing one pitch on a few dozen contacts, but every follow-up is manual and it all goes out from your store inbox. lemlist Email ($69/user/month) fits a team where several people send.

Pick by your situation

  • You pitch stockists, gift buyers or creators every monthInstantly Growth at $47/month. Write the sequence once; follow-ups go out by themselves and stop on a reply.
  • You want to keep outreach away from the inbox that sends order emailsInstantly, with two or three inboxes on a second domain. Growth includes unlimited inboxes and warmup at no extra cost.
  • You only want to test one pitch on 30 to 50 contacts firstGmail mail merge on Workspace Business Standard, then move the list to Instantly once the pitch gets replies.
  • Two or three people on your team each run their own outreachlemlist Email at $69 per user per month, with 50,000 emails a month and warmup on every plan.

Built from official pricing and help pages checked 2026-10-31, not hands-on testing. How we research

At a glance

8 min read

On this page

You found 150 boutiques that would suit your products, or 40 creators whose followers look like your customers. You wrote a good email and sent it. Then nothing happened.

Store owners describe the same thing on the Shopify Community. One emailed 25 creators and got 1 reply. Another sent 50 creator invites and got no applications, and a third asked what reply rate to expect at all. Others worry about the opposite problem: that a big list will land in spam or get the account flagged.

Both problems point to the same habits: send a modest number of emails per inbox, from inboxes that are warmed up, and follow up with everyone who did not answer. This page compares three ways to do that. All prices are list prices checked on 2026-10-31.

Why one email is not enough

A founder on Hacker News who looked back at their cold email results said the key differentiating factor was follow-ups. A Shopify Community guide on pitching creators and journalists suggests following up once after a few days.

Doing follow-ups by hand takes the most work. You check who replied, skip them, and send the next email to everyone else on the right day, for every person on the list. One owner trying to do this inside Shopify Collabs could not even send personalized invites with name fields in one go.

The three in one table

Instantly Gmail mail merge lemlist
Entry price Growth, $47/mo ($37.60/mo billed yearly) Google Workspace Business Standard, $14/user/mo (annual) Email, $69/user/mo ($55/mo billed yearly)
Automatic follow-ups Yes, stops on reply No, you send each one Yes, stops on reply
Sending inboxes Unlimited Your one account Unlimited
Warmup Unlimited, included None lemwarm, included
Sending volume 5,000 emails/mo, 1,000 uploaded contacts Up to 1,500 recipients/day 50,000 emails/mo per user
Unsubscribe link You add it Added automatically You add it
Start Free, no credit card Part of Workspace 14-day trial

Instantly’s next plan, Hypergrowth, is $97 a month ($77.60 billed yearly) for 125,000 emails and 25,000 uploaded contacts. lemlist Multichannel is $109 per user per month ($87 yearly).

Worked example: 200 boutiques, three emails each

Say you pitch 200 boutiques with three emails: the pitch, a nudge four days later, and your line sheet a week after that. For the example, assume 20% of the people still in the sequence reply after each of the first two emails.

  • Email 1: 200 sends
  • Email 2: 200 − 40 replies = 160 sends
  • Email 3: 160 − 32 replies = 128 sends
  • Total: 488 emails, 288 of them follow-ups
Instantly Growth Gmail mail merge lemlist Email
Fits the volume? Yes, 488 of 5,000 Yes, under 1,500/day Yes, 488 of 50,000
The 288 follow-ups Sent on schedule, repliers skipped You filter the sheet and send them yourself Sent on schedule, repliers skipped
Sending inbox Two or three outreach inboxes Your store inbox Outreach inboxes
Monthly cost $47 ($37.60 yearly) $14 (annual) $69 per user ($55 yearly)

The reply rate is made up for the example; the limits and prices come from the vendors’ pages. At Instantly’s recommended 30 campaign emails per inbox per day, 488 emails over 15 sending days is about 33 a day, so two warmed-up inboxes cover it with room to spare.

To run your own numbers: list size × emails in your sequence, minus the people who reply, is your monthly send count.

Instantly: built for this job

Instantly sends cold email sequences from many inboxes at once. Every outreach plan includes unlimited sending accounts and warmup, so adding inboxes does not raise the price. A Shopify Community member setting up cold outreach put it simply: “I use instantly for cold emailing, and it includes warming up.”

What it does for a store owner

  • Follow-ups without the spreadsheet. You write the pitch and the follow-ups once. Instantly sends each step on the day you set and drops anyone who replies.
  • Outreach kept off your store inbox. You can connect two or three inboxes on a second domain and let Instantly rotate between them. If one inbox gets spam reports, order confirmations still go out from your main address.
  • Warmup included. Instantly’s help center recommends warming a new inbox at 10 emails a day for at least two weeks before campaigns, then sending about 30 campaign emails per inbox per day. Warmup runs in the background on every plan.
  • Room to grow. Growth covers 5,000 emails and 1,000 uploaded contacts a month. If you start pitching larger creator lists, Hypergrowth raises that to 125,000 emails and 25,000 contacts.

What to know before you start

  • Contact data is separate. The B2B database (450M+ contacts) is sold as credit plans. If you build your list from shops and creators you found yourself, you do not need it.
  • You add the legal footer. Put your postal address and an unsubscribe line in the email template, as CAN-SPAM requires.
  • Plan for two weeks of warmup before the first campaign on a new inbox.

You can start Instantly free with no credit card and warm up your inboxes while you build your list.

Gmail mail merge: fine for a first test

Google added mail merge to Gmail for Workspace Individual and the Standard and Plus tiers of Business, Enterprise and Education. You write one email with fields like first name and shop name, pick a Google Sheet, and each person gets their own copy.

It is a cheap way to test whether a pitch gets any replies before you commit to a sequence. Gmail adds an unsubscribe link to each merge email for you, and one account can send to 1,500 recipients a day.

The limits show up once you pitch regularly:

  • Every follow-up is manual. You track replies in the sheet and send the next email yourself.
  • Everything goes out from your store inbox. Spam reports from outreach count against the same address that sends receipts. A commenter on Hacker News warns that Google suspends accounts that get lots of spam reports.
  • No warmup and no inbox rotation.
  • Business Starter does not include it. The $7 plan is not on Google’s eligible list.

lemlist: when several people send

lemlist prices per user. Its Email plan gives each user 50,000 emails a month, unlimited sending inboxes and lemwarm, which lemlist includes on all plans. It suits a store where the founder pitches wholesale and someone else handles creators, each with their own seat.

For one person sending a few hundred emails a month, the per-user price is the catch: $69 a month against $47 for Instantly Growth, which does the same core job. Lead data is an add-on ($20/month for 2,000 enrichment credits).

The rules that apply whatever tool you pick

United States (CAN-SPAM). The FTC says the law makes no exception for business-to-business email. Every message needs accurate sender details, a subject line that matches the content, a clear note that it is an ad, a valid postal address (a registered PO box works), and an opt-out you honor within 10 business days. Each violating email can cost up to $53,088.

Gmail’s sender rules. Every sender to Gmail addresses needs SPF or DKIM on the sending domain and a spam rate below 0.3% in Google Postmaster Tools, with 0.10% as Google’s target. Above 5,000 messages a day, you also need DMARC and one-click unsubscribe.

United Kingdom (PECR). The ICO says you can email corporate bodies such as limited companies without prior consent, and should keep a “do not email” list for those who object. Sole traders and some partnerships count as individuals and need to have consented, so check whether a shop is a limited company before you email it. The ICO notes this guidance is under review.

Elsewhere, including the EU, check local rules before you send.

Common mistakes

  1. Stopping after one email. Plan at least one follow-up before you send the first message.
  2. Sending outreach from your store inbox. Keep it on separate inboxes so spam reports stay away from your order emails.
  3. Starting a new inbox at full speed. Warm it up for two weeks first, as Instantly’s help center recommends.
  4. Buying a list. You don’t know who on a bought list agreed to anything or whether the addresses still work, and every spam report counts toward Google’s 0.3% line.
  5. Leaving out what a buyer needs. Put your wholesale price, minimum order and shipping terms in the first email or the line sheet you link to.
  6. Forgetting the postal address. Use the business address from your legal pages.

What to do this week

  1. Build your list in a Google Sheet: shop or creator name, contact name, email, and one line on why your product fits them.
  2. Set up SPF and DKIM on your domain. Our domain and email setup guide covers it.
  3. Open an Instantly account and connect two outreach inboxes on a second domain. Turn warmup on now so the inboxes are ready in two weeks.
  4. Write a three-step sequence while they warm up: the pitch, a short nudge after four days, and your line sheet a week later.
  5. Want to test the pitch first? Send it to 30 to 50 contacts with Gmail mail merge, keep what gets replies, then load the full list into Instantly.

Sources (checked 2026-10-31)

  • Instantly: Pricing: Growth $47/mo ($37.60 yearly), 5,000 emails, 1,000 uploaded contacts, unlimited email accounts and warmup; Hypergrowth $97/mo ($77.60 yearly), 125,000 emails, 25,000 contacts; separate lead credit plans; no credit card to start.
  • Instantly Help: Campaign Options: 30 campaign emails + 10 warmup emails per inbox per day.
  • Instantly Help: How warm-up works and Warmup Settings: 10 warmup emails a day for new accounts, at least 2 weeks before campaigns.
  • lemlist: Pricing: Email $69/user/mo ($55 yearly), 50,000 emails/mo, unlimited sending accounts; Multichannel $109 ($87 yearly); lemwarm on all plans; 14-day trial; enrichment add-on $20/mo for 2k credits.
  • Google: Mail merge in Gmail: eligible editions, 1,500 recipients per day, automatic unsubscribe link.
  • Google Workspace: Pricing: Business Starter $7, Business Standard $14 per user per month (annual).
  • Google: Email sender guidelines: SPF or DKIM for all senders, spam rate below 0.3% (target 0.10%), DMARC and one-click unsubscribe above 5,000 messages a day.
  • FTC: CAN-SPAM Act compliance guide: no B2B exception, requirements, 10 business days, up to $53,088 per email.
  • ICO: Electronic mail marketing: corporate bodies vs sole traders under PECR.
  • Store-owner threads on the Shopify Community and Hacker News, linked where quoted above.

This article is for general information and is not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Why does nobody reply to my first email?
Store owners on the Shopify Community describe 1 reply from 25 creators and no applications from 50 invites. A founder on Hacker News named follow-ups as the factor that made their cold email work. A tool like Instantly sends those follow-ups for you and stops as soon as someone replies.
Can cold email get my store inbox flagged?
It can. Gmail expects senders to keep their spam rate below 0.3%, and a commenter on Hacker News warns that Google suspends accounts that collect many spam reports. Sending outreach from separate inboxes on a second domain keeps that risk away from the address that sends order confirmations.
Is cold email to shops legal in the US?
Yes, if you follow CAN-SPAM. The FTC says the law makes no exception for business-to-business email: use accurate sender details, an honest subject line, say the message is an ad, include a postal address and honor opt-outs within 10 business days. Each violating email can cost up to $53,088.
How many cold emails can one inbox send a day?
Instantly's help center recommends 30 campaign emails plus 10 warmup emails per inbox per day, and at least two weeks of warmup for a new inbox before campaigns. To send more, you add inboxes, which Instantly Growth allows without limit.
Does Instantly include a contact list?
Not in the outreach plans. Instantly sells its B2B lead database (450M+ contacts) as separate credit plans. If you find boutiques and creators yourself, you only need the outreach plan.

Written by

Kitmere

Kitmere is an independent publication. We read the official sources, test tools on real tasks and write down what we find.