Wickfield Candle Co. is a made-up shop for this demo, not a real business.
Tools used and what they cost
| Tool | Used for | Cost in this demo |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify Tax | Calculates sales tax at checkout for US stores and gives a US sales tax report by state, county and jurisdiction | Free until your store's sales reach $100,000 USD (annual for stores created before May 13, 2026, lifetime for newer stores). After that, 0.35% on Basic, Grow or Advanced, capped at $0.99 per order, on orders from regions where you collect tax. Charged to you on your Shopify bill, not to customers. Automated filing: closed to new enrollmentChecked Oct 16, 2026 · source |
| Wave | Free bookkeeping and invoicing records | Starter $0: unlimited invoices, bills and bookkeeping records, bank transactions added by hand. Pro $19/mo or $190/yr adds bank import and receipt capture. Sales tax features: not confirmed on the pricing pageChecked Oct 16, 2026 · source |
| QuickBooks Online | Accounting software; income and expense tracking on the free plan | Free $0: 1 user, 1 connected bank account, profit and loss report, 2 invoices a month, no mobile app or integrations. Simple Start $38/mo list price, 30-day free trial. Sales Tax AI listed from Plus ($140/mo list)Checked Oct 16, 2026 · source |
| FreshBooks | Invoicing and bookkeeping with tax-time reports | 30-day free trial, no credit card. Lite $23/mo list price for 5 billable clients (promo shown: 80% off for 4 months). Tax-time reports on every plan. Which plans include the Sales Tax Summary report: not confirmedChecked Oct 16, 2026 · source |
On January 26, 2025, a new store owner posted on Shopify Community under the title I need help understanding whether or not I need to file for taxes as a brand new business. She wrote: “I am a crafter who wants to sell the things she makes.” She had built the site and added all her products. She had no sales yet and hadn’t registered a business, because she didn’t want to spend a lot on something that might not work out.
Only payments, taxes and shipping were left to set up. Then Shopify showed her a banner: “you have no sales tax liabilities.” She read it as “I don’t have to set up taxes” and asked the forum if that was right. She also asked whether she needed tax set up in other states, or only her home state.
The replies didn’t give her a yes or no. One told her to talk to a qualified accounting professional, not strangers online. Another said each state has different rules, so start with where you live and sell. She never posted again, and nothing in the thread is marked as the answer.
This page is not tax advice. It is the three checks the reel covers, in order, with the official page behind each one. We have not tested a live store for this page.
Why “no liabilities” doesn’t mean “no setup”
You don’t owe sales tax on sales you haven’t made. That part of the banner is fine. The catch is that owing tax and needing to register are two different things.
Shopify’s US tax liability page says the insights work from your store’s data in Shopify, and that the page “is not a substitute for advice from a tax authority or a tax professional.” The same page says that when you have a business location in a state, you automatically have a physical liability there. A store with no sales has no sales data to flag, but you may still have a location.
Check 1: your home state may count from day one
Shopify’s guide to understanding tax liability says you “might have a physical nexus in at least the state where your store is based.” Nexus is the link to a state that can mean you have to register and collect its sales tax. “Might” is the honest word here: it depends on your state and what you sell.
So the first question goes to your home state, not Shopify:
- Open the IRS list of State government websites and pick your state.
- On your state’s page, look under Taxation for the state’s revenue or tax department.
- On that agency’s site, find the business or sales tax registration section and check whether you need to register before your first sale.
If the agency’s site doesn’t answer your case, call them or ask a local tax professional. That is what Shopify’s guide itself says to do when it’s unclear.
Other states work differently. Shopify says economic nexus rules apply to all merchants with US customers, and each state sets its own rules. We don’t list any state’s numbers here, because they vary and they change. Check each state’s rules with that state when your sales there grow.
Check 2: register with your state, then turn on collection
The order matters. Shopify’s US tax setup guide says: “After you’ve registered with the tax agencies and have your sales tax ID, you can set up your taxes collection.”
Once you have the sales tax ID, Shopify’s steps are:
- In your Shopify admin, go to Settings > Taxes and duties.
- In the Manage sales tax collection section, click United States.
- In Regional settings, click Add new state.
- Select the state where you’re registered.
- Enter your sales tax ID.
- Click Collect taxes.
Say you run Wickfield Candle Co. from one state. If your state tells you to register, you register there first, then add only that state in Shopify. You don’t add states you aren’t registered in.
Check 3: collecting isn’t filing, and filing is on you
Shopify’s US taxes page says: “Shopify doesn’t remit or file your taxes for you, unless you use Shopify Tax and set up automated filing.”
There’s a catch for new stores. Shopify’s automated filing pricing page now says “Automated filing is closed to new enrollment,” and that if your store isn’t already enrolled, it “can’t be turned on.” So for a store opening today, Shopify can collect the tax at checkout, but filing the return and paying the state is your job.
What that means in practice:
- When you register, note how often your state wants returns, and put the dates in your calendar. Your state sets this, so read it on the state’s site.
- Keep the tax you collect separate in your head and your records. It isn’t your money.
- Before each return, pull the numbers from Shopify. Its tax reports page says the United States sales tax report (for stores on Shopify Tax) breaks sales and tax down by state, county and jurisdiction, and that “the Jurisdiction report can be used when you prepare a sales tax return yourself.” The Total sales by order export gives you or your accountant the gross sales, net sales, taxes, returns and shipping for the period.
So, do you owe tax with no sales?
No. But you may need to register first. Ask your state. Shopify’s banner can’t answer that for you, and neither can a forum.
Tools that help (optional)
You don’t need a paid tool to do the three checks. They’re a state website, a Shopify settings page and a calendar. Tools help with the part that comes after: calculating tax at checkout and keeping clean records for each return.
| Tool | What it helps with | Free plan or entry price | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify Tax | Calculates US sales tax at checkout; US sales tax report for preparing returns | Free until your store passes $100,000 in sales, then 0.35% per order (max $0.99) on Basic, Grow or Advanced | Oct 16, 2026 |
| Wave | Bookkeeping records and invoices | Starter $0; Pro $19/mo | Oct 16, 2026 |
| QuickBooks Online | Income and expense tracking, profit and loss report | Free $0 (1 user, 1 bank account); Simple Start $38/mo list | Oct 16, 2026 |
| FreshBooks | Invoicing, bookkeeping, tax-time reports | 30-day free trial; Lite $23/mo list | Oct 16, 2026 |
Sources: Shopify Tax pricing, Wave pricing, QuickBooks pricing, FreshBooks pricing. The Shopify Tax threshold is Shopify’s rule for its own fee, not a tax rule from any state. Shopify says the fee is added to your Shopify bill, “isn’t charged to your customers,” and applies only to orders from regions where you collect tax. Store owners pay it, and the sales tax itself still goes to your state when you file.
None of these tools registers you with your state, and none of them can tell you whether you need to. Do Check 1 first. Prices change, so check the pricing page before you sign up.


